Why JEE Main is a total farce?
Prabha Dhavala, 18 May 2018, #JEE Main
Manipal Institute of Technology
Manipal Institute of Technology
SRM Institute of Science and Technology
SRM Institute Of Science And Technology

April 30 was a big day for most engineering aspirants. CBSE had released the results for JEE Main and also the cut offs for appearing in JEE Advanced. It is this cut-off that is widely misunderstood by students and parents. Many count this as a qualifying cut-off and assume that if they have not got the marks equal to or above it, they have not qualified in the exam. This is the biggest myth of JEE Main.  So is there a cut off to get rank in JEE Main?


IMPORTANT - JEE Knockout Crash Course Available for JEE 2019 Aspirants
[A personalized course to clear IIT / JEE 2019 with the access of Mock Test Series ( Subject & Topic Wise ), Video Lecture, Most Asked Questions, Prep Boosters, 17 Years Solved Papers, Personalized Strength Sheet and more. Get Now]

B.Tech Admissions Open 2019
SRM Institute Of Science And Technology

 

JEE Main Sample Paper

Download Free Sample Paper For JEE Main

Download Now

How it began?

Admissions Open Now
SRM University AP-Amaravati B.Tech Admissions
B.Tech Admissions 2019 | International collaboration with UC Berkeley
Apply
UPES - School of Engineering
B.Tech Admissions 2019 Open | 1064+ Recruiters | Scholarships on offer
Apply

 It started with an innocent query, “How much should I score to pass JEE Main”? We searched for an answer and were surprised to discover there were no qualifying marks. We filed RTIS to find out the corresponding marks for JEE ranks. This is what we found:

 

Prepare for IIT / JEE Main 2019 with concept and topic wise videos by exam experts. Get the complete course videos direct to your inbox. Click to Subscribe

 

 

JEE Main 2017 statistics

JEE Main Paper I

Details

Applied

1198988

Appeared

1134885

Last rank

1122351

Marks obtained by Last rank

Physics -29, Maths - 25 and Chemistry -30

No. of candidates who got 0 marks

14685

No. of candidates who got -ve marks

 81739

What does this mean?

As the table above shows of the 11.34 lakh students who appeared for JEE Main 2017, about 11.22 students got a rank. And this includes about 96 thousand students who got both zero and negative marks (Column 6 and 7 respectively). In other words every student who appears for the exam and is not debarred will get a rank.  THERE IS NO QUALIFYING MARKS FOR THE MOST PRESTIGIOUS ENGINEERING ENTRANCE EXAM IN THE COUNTRY.

 

What is the result?

And this has resulted in many NITs especially in North East actually admitting students who have either obtained less than zero or around single digit scores into engineering courses.

Institute Name

Branch

Quota

Opening Rank

Closing Rank

National Institute of Technology Sikkim

Civil Engineering

HS

361365

1044649

National Institute of Technology, Manipur

Mechanical Engineering

HS

459935

901831

National Institute of Technology Sikkim

Electrical and Electronics Engineering

HS

292501

1017353

National Institute of Technology Sikkim

Electronics and Communication Engineering

HS

487442

974399

National Institute of Technology, Mizoram

Computer Science and Engineering

HS

231177

914353

National Institute of Technology, Mizoram

Electrical and Electronics Engineering

HS

912787

912787

What is wrong?

Every prestigious exam in the country has a minimum qualifying percentage or percentile. In case of NEET, it is the 50th percentile for general category and 40th for reserved categories. But here there is none.  How can CBSE not have a minimum qualifying criterion? Protecting the state’s interest may be fine but doing so at the cost of allowing undeserving candidates admission is detrimental to the national interest.  It also does nobody good especially the student who will be left coping up with a difficult and competitive environment and is patently not qualified to enter in.

 

What does this mean for students?

This is a matter of serious concern. It is seen that 25,220 seats are in totality available to students across categories in all the NITs, IIITs and CFTIs and the total number of students who appear for the exam are around 12 lakhs. Without a qualifying cut-off, anyone can apply and get a rank. This means that in spite of bad marks, zero marks or minus marks; a student can participate in the counselling for admissions.

In the normal course, every exam including a class test in school has a certain pass mark that is used as a benchmark for qualifying or moving to the next step. Even JEE Advanced has a certain qualifying cut-off as does GATE, NEET, .NET and every other exam that is conducted by CBSE. It is only JEE Main that doesn’t have one. Therefore, if there is no qualifying mark to determine if a student should stand a chance of applying for admissions, it means that the exam is completely pointless as there is every chance of misuse by students who vie for admissions in spite of being ineligible in every sense.

Now by applying a cut off there is a possibility that some NITs do not find qualified candidates for all the seats in their home state quota. And this is a good sign because such seats then can then revert to the national pool and more qualified candidates would get the seat.

Otherwise a minus 2 marks candidate who has been given an All India rank of 1009588, will get a civil engineering seat in NIT, Sikkim under state quota while as a 20000 rank holder with say 280-300 marks who does not belong to Sikkim will be left to fend for himself or herself. And that is a farce!

Admissions Open Now

MIT School of Bioengineering S..
Apply
Manipal Institute of Technolog..
Apply
SRM University AP-Amaravati B...
Apply
Chandigarh University
Apply
Manav Rachna International Ins..
Apply
Banasthali Vidyapith, Banastha..
Apply
Amity University B.Tech Admiss..
Apply
View All Application Forms

More like JEE Main

Questions related to JEE Main

How should I study for JEE Main in 1 month after my Board exam gets over on 11th March,2019?

22 Minutes ago

So I am basically gonna tell you the weightage of all the topics subject wise:Physics:A) According to Syllabus Weightage-In the physics portion for...

I got 75 in english, 65 in physics, 65 in chemistry, 85 in biology, 85 in alternative english and 48 in maths. My percentage is 75%.

36 Minutes ago

Hello Dipankar, as your percentage is not 75% if you add Maths in Place of biology, and you have said that you are in top 20 percentile of your boa...

Can i admission in LPU depeds on the marks of jee main or ranking in jee main

2 Hours ago

Hello Jaideep,You can't take admission to LPU based on JEE score as LPU conducts their own entrance for admission process of B.Tech known as Nation...

I got 81 percentile(general category) in jee main January will I get mechanical engineering at any NIT

3 Hours ago

Hii pravinFor the percentile you mentioned will be having general rank around 170000. So you have very low chances to get any NITs with any branch....

Can I correct JEE application's January mistakes in April attempt? Such as category etc ? Is there any option?

2 Hours ago

Hiii.... One can't change category like obc to sc/st or so.You can only change your category from general to others.Or from others to general categ...

Download the Careers360 App on your Android phone

Regular exam updates, QnA, Predictors, College Applications & E-books now on your Mobile

Careers360 App
150M+ Students
24,000+ Colleges
500+ Exams
1500+ E-books