JEE Main, Advanced: Data Shows CBSE Students Have A Clear Advantage

The CBSE edge

Conducted over February-March, Careers360’s The Big Questions survey tried to understand which boards students who have written the JEE Main and JEE Advanced examinations come from and how they prepare. The respondents were top rankers of the two exams who had a fair chance of getting into IITs, National Institutes of Technology (NIT), Indian Institutes of Information Technology (IIITs) and other government-funded institutions (GFTIs).

In all, 1,526 students responded. Of them, 666 students are currently studying in an IITs, 378 in NITs, and 142 in IIITs. As many as 1,186 of the 1,526 students surveyed – 78% -- achieved their objective of studying in one of the top most institutions of the country. Considering their scores, the rest may have joined GFTIs or other elite institutions. Also, 1,133 of the 1,526 students – 84% -- joined the institutions in 2020 and 2021 and are pursuing BTech degrees in different branches.

Of these 1,526 students, 1,350 also responded to the question on the school board they belonged to. The result, consistent with the 2018 official data, shows how critical the choice of school board is for cracking the JEE and how the CBSE students enjoy an undeniable edge. Given below is how the respondents were distributed across boards.

Board-wise students who sat for JEE

State boards, CBSE, private schools

According to the UDISE Plus, India’s main public database on schooling, the country has a total of 15,09,136 schools. However, the number of senior secondary schools – with Classes 11 and 12 – is 1,44,088. The vast majority of senior secondary schools are affliated to state boards. Their distribution is given below.

Classes 11, 12: School Distribution By Board

Rest of the schools are unaffiliated.

While the UDISE data does not show the distribution of enrolled students by secondary board of examination, data released by the boards at the time of conducting the Class 12 exams shows that CBSE students form a small fraction the total student population at that level, in the country. In 2021, CBSE had 13.04 lakh students, across states, writing the Class 12 exams. Tamil Nadu (TN) board alone had 8.16 lakh; Maharashtra HSC board had 13.19 lakh; Bihar board (BSEB) had 13.4 lakh and Uttar Pradesh (UP Board or UPMSP), India’s largest school board, had a staggering 29.94 lakh registering or writing the exam. These are just four states.

With schooling being mostly state-funded and governed, it is natural that most students should attend state schools. However, in a national-level entrance exam system that is truly equitable and fair, this distribution would also reflect in the students qualifying the exams. However, that is not the case. National exams, clearly and indisputably, favour CBSE students.

Given below are the boards that did best and worst in the 2018 round of JEE Advanced.

JEE Advanced 2018: Best And Worst

Hidden within this bias is another one. While the CBSE is a public board in that that it is an autonomous body directly under the ministry of education, the vast majority of schools affiliated to it are private unaided. In 2018, the same year as the IIT Kanpur report, the total number of CBSE schools grew to 20,354, according to the board’s official website. Of these, over 15,000 were private. Given below is the distribution of CBSE schools by management type.

Distribution of CBSE schools in 2018 (Source: CBSE Official Website)

Why CBSE dominates

The central exams, including the new examinations such as the Common University Entrance Test (CUET) are uniformly all based on the textbooks of the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT), a central advisory body on curriculum and textbook design. While some state boards have been pushed to adopt NCERT textbooks directly or modified versions of them, CBSE textbooks are all NCERT books. An exam syllabus “based on NCERT” is essentially code for CBSE syllabus.

There is also significant overlap between students writing the JEE and junior level scholarship competitions and Olympiads in Classes 9 and 10. The syllabus for these is also based on the NCERT textbooks, and therefore, would be most familiar to CBSE students. This, in turn, means CBSE students aiming to write the JEE get early exposure to the textbooks and syllabus.

A large number of government schools affiliated to the state boards may teach in the regional languages and that may make preparation further difficult. Although the NTA started conducting JEE Main in 13 languages in 2021, the number of students writing in languages other than English is very small.

The choice of the board is a choice made by the student and their parents. However, if your primary objective is to crack a central examination after Class 12, data suggests that the CBSE may be a better choice.